top of page

Recipe: Vanilla Chai Sugar Cookie Sandwiches

Oct 12
2 min read

One of my favorite things to do in my spare time is trying/adapting new recipes. This takes my favorite sugar cookie recipe and adds a fall twist! Make sure to leave enough time for the dough to chill overnight before baking.



Vanilla Chai Sugar Cookies


Ingredients:

226g unsalted butter (room temp)

200g granulated sugar

120g powdered sugar

2 large eggs

3 tsp vanilla extract

360g all purpose flour

2 bags of chai tea (I used Trader Joe's Spiced Chai. Use one bag for milder flavor)

1 tsp baking soda

1/2 tsp baking powder

1/2 tsp salt


Other items I used:

parchment paper

4” English muffin rings

Food scale

Stand mixer

Piping bags + tips

Container for chilling in fridge


Directions:

1.) Add butter (226g), granulated sugar (200g), and powdered sugar (120g) to stand mixer and mix for about 2 minutes or until fluffy

2.) Add eggs (2) and vanilla (3 tsp). Scrape the sides of your bowl and mix for 2 minutes

3.) In a separate bowl, add flour (360g), baking soda (1 tsp), baking powder (1/2 tsp), salt (1/2 tsp), and the chai (cut 2 bags open and dump contents). Stir until evenly distributed.

4.) Slowly add dry ingredients to mixer

5.) Mix on medium-low until combined. Dough might be a bit sticky.

6.) Put in a container and refrigerate overnight

I make dough balls about 45-50g to fit into 4” English muffin rings and bake at 350° for around 15 minutes. I use the rings to make sure cookies are exactly the same size and make perfect sandwiches, but you don’t have to do that


Cream Filling


Ingredients:

340g unsalted butter (room temperature)

380g powdered sugar

13oz marshmallow fluff

3 tsp vanilla extract

1/2 tsp salt


Directions:

1.) Put butter (340g) in stand mixer with whisk attachment. Mix on medium-high for 5 minutes, scrape the sides and bottom, and mix for another 5 minutes. Your butter should be a very light yellow.

2.) Slowly add powdered sugar (380g)

3.) Mix until combined, making sure to stop periodically to scrape the sides and bottom.

4.) Add vanilla extract (3 tsp) and salt (1/2 tsp)

5.) Add marshmallow fluff (13oz).

6.) Mix until combined

Optional: to keep things neat, I use a piping bag to pipe the icing



Let me know what you think and if you try this! My taste testers (my family) really loves them.

 
 
bottom of page